Why your team will win the 2024 World Series hinges on their ability to harness momentum and capitalize on key player performances. This postseason promises unpredictability, with Major League Baseball (MLB) showcasing an unprecedented level of competition. The Texas Rangers, last year’s champions, face a unique challenge as they enter October without the title to defend, marking a significant shift in postseason dynamics.
While familiar favorites emerge alongside new contenders, history teaches that regular-season success does not guarantee playoff triumph. The next four weeks will determine which teams can ignite their performance when it matters most. With 12 teams remaining, the stakes are high, and each has the potential to make a deep run.
According to FOX Sports MLB analysts Rowan Kavner and Deesha Thosar, each postseason participant will be examined for their chances to clinch the World Series title in 2024.
(Teams are organized by seeding, with World Series odds sourced from FanDuel Sportsbook.)
AMERICAN LEAGUE
1. New York Yankees
World Series odds: +450
Why they’ll be 2024 World Series champions: The Yankees possess the most potent offense in the American League. Despite a noticeable decline in production beyond their star players, they consistently overpower opposing pitchers. The combination of Aaron Judge and Juan Soto presents a formidable challenge for any pitcher. If Giancarlo Stanton can replicate his impressive postseason performance and Austin Wells finds his rhythm, the Yankees will be difficult to navigate. The trio of Judge, Soto, and Gerrit Cole firing on all cylinders gives New York a significant edge in their pursuit of the Fall Classic.
2. Cleveland Guardians
World Series odds: +1100
Why they’ll be 2024 World Series champions: The Guardians boast the top bullpen and closer in Major League Baseball. Emmanuel Clase’s remarkable 0.61 ERA and 34 consecutive successful save opportunities set a high standard. The combined strength of Clase, Hunter Gaddis, Tim Herrin, and Cade Smith, all with ERAs below 2.00, makes Cleveland’s bullpen a formidable barrier. With José Ramírez supported by power hitters Josh Naylor and Lane Thomas, the Guardians can secure early leads, making it challenging for opponents to recover.
Why they won’t: While Cleveland’s bullpen can stifle opponents, their offense ranks 17th in OPS and has struggled since the All-Star break. The Guardians’ low hard-hit rate and starting pitching challenges could hinder their postseason success. Their only significant addition, Alex Cobb, has been limited by injury, and the rotation lacks the depth needed to compete at the highest level. — Rowan Kavner
3. Houston Astros
World Series odds: +850
Why they’ll be 2024 World Series champions: The Astros are a team that cannot be underestimated. Their remarkable comeback from a 10-game deficit in late June to clinch the AL West showcases their resilience. With a history of playoff success and a roster filled with talent, Houston is equipped to intimidate opponents. The experience gained from previous playoff runs can be a decisive factor as they aim for another championship.
Why they won’t: Concerns arise from Yordan Alvarez’s knee injury and the uncertainties surrounding first-year manager Joe Espada. Alvarez’s absence could significantly impact the lineup, and his ability to contribute remains in question. The Astros must navigate the playoffs with potential managerial nerves and the challenges of a less experienced roster. — Deesha Thosar
4. Baltimore Orioles
World Series odds: +900
Why they’ll be 2024 World Series champions: The Orioles made an impressive start to the season, showcasing their potential as a top contender. With a young roster that has gained valuable experience, they aim to capitalize on their momentum. If they can regain their early-season form, they could pose a significant threat in the playoffs.
Why they won’t: However, the Orioles have struggled since the All-Star break, particularly in the bullpen, which ranks 27th in ERA. Their inability to capitalize on key opportunities has raised concerns about their readiness for the postseason. The lack of consistency from key players could prove detrimental as they face tougher competition. — Deesha Thosar
5. Kansas City Royals
World Series odds: +2500
Why they’ll be 2024 World Series champions: The Royals feature standout Bobby Witt Jr., who is having a historic season for a shortstop. With a pitching staff that boasts the lowest ERA among playoff teams, they possess the tools to make a significant impact in the postseason. Their recent performances suggest they could surprise many in October.
Why they won’t: Yet, the Royals face challenges, including a recent losing streak and injuries impacting their lineup. The absence of Vinnie Pasquantino has exposed weaknesses in their offense, and their bullpen, while improving, still struggles overall. These factors may hinder their chances for a deep playoff run. — Rowan Kavner
6. Detroit Tigers
World Series odds: +2700
Why they’ll be 2024 World Series champions: The Tigers are fueled by youthful talent and a strong bullpen that ranks among the best in the league. Emerging players like Riley Greene and Kerry Carpenter have contributed significantly, and their recent success could provide the momentum needed for an upset in the playoffs.
Why they won’t: However, their lack of postseason experience and depth in pitching could be detrimental. The Tigers must overcome the challenges of inexperience and injuries to key players to advance in the playoffs. — Deesha Thosar
NATIONAL LEAGUE
1. Los Angeles Dodgers
World Series odds: +350
Why they’ll be 2024 World Series champions: The Dodgers, despite recent injuries, have secured the top seed in the National League. With stars like Shohei Ohtani, Mookie Betts, and Freddie Freeman, they possess the offensive firepower to compete at the highest level. Their recent acquisitions may provide the necessary depth to address pitching concerns.
Why they won’t: However, their pitching rotation faces significant challenges, with key players unavailable for postseason play. The reliance on less experienced pitchers could prove risky as they attempt to navigate the playoffs. — Rowan Kavner
2. Philadelphia Phillies
World Series odds: +360
Why they’ll be 2024 World Series champions: The Phillies present a well-rounded team with a strong starting rotation and a high-powered offense. Their determination to succeed after recent playoff disappointments drives their ambition to secure a championship. With their first division title since 2011, they enter October as formidable contenders.
3. Milwaukee Brewers
World Series odds: +1900
Why they won’t: However, the Brewers face challenges with an underperforming offense and questions about their pitching rotation. Their recent struggles could hinder their chances of advancing in the playoffs. — Rowan Kavner
4. San Diego Padres
World Series odds: +1100
Why they’ll be 2024 World Series champions: The Padres have transformed their offense and possess a strong pitching staff. Their recent success in the second half of the season positions them as serious contenders. With a blend of experienced players and emerging stars, they have the potential for a deep playoff run.
Why they won’t: Nonetheless, concerns about their ninth-inning stability and injuries to key players could impact their postseason performance. The Padres must address these issues to maximize their chances. — Rowan Kavner
5. Atlanta Braves
World Series odds: +2500
Why they won’t: Despite their resilience, the Braves face significant injury challenges among key players, which could impact their depth and overall performance. Their recent struggles at the plate raise concerns as they approach the postseason. — Deesha Thosar
6. New York Mets
World Series odds: +3200
Why they’ll be 2024 World Series champions: The Mets have shown a remarkable turnaround this season, demonstrating strong team chemistry and a resurgence in performance. With key players like Francisco Lindor and Edwin Díaz leading the charge, they have the potential to surprise in the playoffs.
Why they won’t: However, questions remain about the overall strength of their rotation and the ability of certain pitchers to perform under pressure. The Mets must navigate these uncertainties to make a significant playoff run. — Deesha Thosar
