Dave Roberts deserves to be MLB’s highest-paid manager due to his remarkable leadership and ability to adapt in high-pressure situations. Over the years, Roberts has transformed from a manager often criticized for his playoff decisions into a respected figure who has successfully guided the Los Angeles Dodgers through various challenges.
On May 26 of the previous season, Yohan Ramirez found himself struggling in the eighth inning, facing a situation he had never encountered in his five-year MLB career. After hitting two batters and walking another in his first game of the series against the Cincinnati Reds, Ramirez’s erratic performance raised alarms. Loading the bases prompted Roberts to leave the dugout, but instead of pulling Ramirez, he chose to trust the reliever.
Roberts’ unique approach has been echoed by other Dodgers players, who highlight his ability to connect with them and maintain a positive atmosphere. This positivity is crucial for managing a roster filled with star talent. He has adeptly handled not only game strategies but also the egos and off-field distractions that can arise in a high-stakes environment. His leadership has consistently resulted in impressive seasons, including multiple 100-win campaigns.
Teoscar Hernandez, who celebrated a World Series victory with the Dodgers, remarked on Roberts’ impact: “It’s just the confidence that he gives to the players. He lets you have fun. His communication with his players is one of the best that I had in my career. And I think that’s why he’s so special for this team.”
With Roberts at the helm, the Dodgers have made the playoffs in all nine of his seasons, placing him among the elite managers in MLB history with five 100-win seasons. His recent performance, particularly in managing a depleted pitching staff during the 2024 season, showcases his growth and strategic acumen. He deserves recognition as one of the highest-paid managers, given the financial backing the Dodgers have committed to building a championship-caliber team.
Andrew Friedman, the president of baseball operations, noted the various injuries the team faced during the season, stating, “You could see where it was a little deflating to the clubhouse. And I think Doc’s relentless optimism helped keep things directionally positive and moving forward.” This optimism was crucial as the Dodgers navigated a franchise-record 40 pitchers throughout the season, a challenge that could have derailed their postseason ambitions.
As the postseason approached, Roberts faced the daunting task of managing a pitching staff that had been significantly weakened. His decision-making was pivotal, as he carefully gauged the abilities of his pitchers. For instance, during a critical moment in the postseason, Roberts chose to trust reliever Blake Treinen, allowing him to face Giancarlo Stanton even when the stakes were high. Treinen’s success in that situation highlighted Roberts’ ability to inspire confidence in his players.
Roberts’ journey as a manager began with recognition as the NL Manager of the Year in 2016. Over the years, he has achieved the highest winning percentage among MLB managers with at least 1,000 games. Despite the financial resources poured into the Dodgers by Guggenheim Baseball Management, Roberts often faced scrutiny, with critics attributing team failures to his decisions during the postseason.
The 2019 NLDS Game 5 remains a notable example of the challenges Roberts faced, when he controversially called on Clayton Kershaw from the bullpen, a decision that backfired. However, the 2020 World Series victory provided Roberts with a measure of vindication, though the pressure remained high as he continued to navigate the complexities of postseason management.
As the Dodgers made significant roster moves, including acquiring Tyler Glasnow and Shohei Ohtani, the ownership group recognized the need for a championship. These moves were part of a broader strategy to enhance the team’s competitiveness, reflecting the high expectations placed on Roberts and his staff.
Roberts’ evolution as a manager is evident in his handling of high-leverage situations. During the 2024 postseason, he emphasized the importance of managing his bullpen effectively, balancing the need to use key pitchers while also preserving their effectiveness over a long series. His ability to adapt and learn from past experiences has made him a more effective leader.
Ultimately, Roberts’ decisions during critical moments saved the Dodgers from potential early exits in the postseason. His strategic choices were described as “surgical” by Friedman, showcasing his ability to maximize the talents of his players. As the team celebrated their championship, Roberts’ leadership was a key factor in their success.
With the pressure of achieving World Series titles each year, Roberts has demonstrated that he thrives in high-stakes situations. His journey culminated in a celebration that solidified his status as a Hall of Fame-caliber manager. As other managers received contract extensions, the anticipation of a record deal for Roberts looms large, affirming his position as the winningest manager in Dodgers postseason history.
