Paul Skenes or Jackson Merrill? This is the question on many baseball fans’ minds as they assess the National League Rookie of the Year race. In a recent discussion with John Smoltz, the MLB on FOX analyst shared insights on the competition between these two promising players. Smoltz believes that Jackson Merrill has indeed made a strong case to surpass Skenes, especially given the dynamics of their respective teams and performance levels.
Kavner: The 2028 Olympics have been a hot topic these days, especially as it relates to Major League Baseball and players potentially being available to play with it being in Los Angeles. Do you think MLB should permit players to play in that, and, if so, how could this possibly look?
Smoltz: Yes, that’s a complicated issue. Historically, it was simpler to include college and minor-league players, but the lengthy MLB season presents challenges. With the World Baseball Classic already capturing some of that Olympic spirit, it’s unclear how major-league players could fit into the Olympic schedule. My experience in the 1984 Junior Olympics was unforgettable, and I know many players would love the opportunity to wear the USA uniform, yet the logistics are tricky.
We’ve talked so much about Paul Skenes, and deservedly so. But has Jackson Merrill done enough at this point to supplant Skenes as the National League Rookie of the Year favorite?
Indeed, Merrill has positioned himself favorably as the season progresses. Smoltz notes that if Pittsburgh, Skenes’ team, falters in playoff contention, it could negatively impact his Rookie of the Year candidacy. Merrill’s dynamic play has made him a standout, and while comparing everyday players to pitchers is challenging, Merrill’s consistent contributions could give him the edge.
When evaluating rookies, Smoltz emphasizes the value of position players who contribute daily versus pitchers who might shine in fewer appearances. While Skenes has had a remarkable season, the impact of someone like Merrill, particularly during a playoff push, cannot be overlooked.
Chris Sale continues to dominate in an otherwise strange year for this Braves team. Do you think there is a sizable gap between him and other NL Cy Young candidates?
Smoltz affirms that Sale is indeed a leading contender for both Comeback Player of the Year and Cy Young honors. His exceptional performance has made him a favorite, and as the season nears its end, he is poised to solidify his status as the frontrunner. The Atlanta Braves have faced challenges, but Sale’s contributions stand out in a year that has been anything but ordinary.
While awards are typically independent of team success, Sale’s ability to elevate a struggling Braves squad adds weight to his candidacy. Smoltz expresses his admiration for Sale’s performance, suggesting that it’s hard to argue against his position as the leading candidate for the Cy Young award.
The Dodgers finally got Mookie Betts back and expect to see a few other starters return soon. Do you think they have the highest ceiling in the National League, or would you say the Phillies despite their recent struggles?
According to Smoltz, the Los Angeles Dodgers possess the highest potential due to their robust organizational resources. However, maintaining health in their pitching rotation remains critical. With Betts back in the lineup, the Dodgers are looking to regain their momentum. On the other hand, the Philadelphia Phillies also have the tools necessary for a World Series run, but their recent performance has raised questions about their consistency.
Smoltz cautions against viewing the race as limited to just two teams. The Milwaukee Brewers have consistently exceeded expectations, proving to be a formidable opponent. Meanwhile, the Braves are showing signs of recovery after a rough patch, adding further intrigue to the playoff landscape.
