The three biggest free-agent needs for the Milwaukee Brewers, Chicago Cubs, St. Louis Cardinals, Cincinnati Reds, and Pittsburgh Pirates are shaping up as the MLB winter meetings approach. Each team is poised to address critical gaps in their rosters, focusing on strategic acquisitions that could significantly impact their performance in the upcoming season.
This analysis starts with the National League Central.
MILWAUKEE BREWERS
1. Second base: The Brewers might consider trading for Angels infielder Luis Rengifo if they decide to shift Turang or Ortiz to shortstop. Rengifo, entering his final arbitration year in 2025, offers versatility as he can play both second and third base. His acquisition could be cost-effective, serving as a one-year solution without depleting Milwaukee’s prospect pool. Another potential target could be Rangers infielder Justin Foscue, who finds himself without a clear path to regular playing time in Texas.
CHICAGO CUBS
1. Starting pitching: The Cubs’ rotation could benefit from a high-caliber starter, yet recent low-cost signings like Jameson Taillon and Shota Imanaga suggest they might not pursue a marquee name like Corbin Burnes. Instead, they might explore free agents like Luis Severino or Frankie Montas, who could fit within their budget. With a top-10 farm system, the Cubs also have the flexibility to engage in trades, potentially pursuing a player like Garrett Crochet.
2. Bullpen: The Cubs should prioritize adding high-leverage relievers after last season’s struggles with Adbert Alzolay and Hector Neris. Potential fits include Clay Holmes, Kenley Jansen, and Chris Martin, who could bolster the bullpen’s effectiveness.
3. Catcher: While the Cubs acquired Matt Thaiss from the Angels, he is better suited as a backup. For a more substantial upgrade, they could target free agents like Kyle Higashioka or Danny Jansen, as Cubs catchers posted a disappointing 69 wRC+ last season, ranking 26th in the league.
ST. LOUIS CARDINALS
1. Starting pitching: With Lance Lynn and Kyle Gibson moving on from their one-year contracts and Miles Mikolas struggling last season, the Cardinals are in dire need of a top-tier left-handed pitcher. Blake Snell and Max Fried stand out as the premier options, while Jose Quintana offers a more affordable alternative. After a rotation ERA of 4.33, ranked 20th in the league, significant upgrades are essential.
2. Relief pitching: The Cardinals need to solidify their bullpen by acquiring a reliable high-leverage arm to complement closer Ryan Helsley, especially after Andrew Kittredge’s departure. Veterans like David Robertson or Aroldis Chapman could provide the necessary experience and stability.
CINCINNATI REDS
1. Designated hitter: The Reds’ designated hitter position was a significant weakness in 2024, with an OPS of .599, placing them 29th in the majors. They might target Joc Pederson, J.D. Martinez, or Andrew McCutchen to enhance their lineup. Additionally, A’s outfielder Brent Rooker could be a viable trade option.
PITTSBURGH PIRATES
1. First base: The Pirates face a dilemma between addressing first base or corner outfield needs. With Rowdy Tellez hitting free agency, Pittsburgh has the opportunity to upgrade. They could explore trading for Ryan Mountcastle from the Orioles, who are rich in position players and could benefit from the Pirates’ pitching depth.
2. Corner outfielder: The Pirates might also consider trading with the Red Sox, who have a surplus of young arms. Wilyer Abreu, a promising rookie with 15 home runs and a 114 wRC+, could be a strategic addition for Pittsburgh, especially as Boston seeks strong pitching options.
