Let the Photoshopping begin.
Juan Soto sweepstakes are heating up as he officially enters the open market, prompting fans across Major League Baseball to envision the young superstar in their team’s colors. The anticipation builds as Soto prepares to sign what could be a record-setting contract, making this offseason a whirlwind for one of the most sought-after free agents in recent history.
Soto has expressed his willingness to join any of MLB’s 30 teams, yet not every franchise is equipped to contend in the postseason or afford his potential price tag. His agent, Scott Boras, is likely to start negotiations with a staggering $500 million offer, which could escalate beyond $600 million depending on the market’s demand for the 26-year-old hitter.
This situation clarifies which teams might realistically pursue Soto, especially as his camp has remained vague about the length of contract he seeks. It is rumored that Soto aims for longevity in his career, possibly looking for a deal that stretches over 14 years, similar to Fernando Tatís Jr.’s record-setting contract with the San Diego Padres.
Could Soto be the Yankees’ to lose? Let’s explore how he fits with various potential suitors. This list isn’t exhaustive, as every front office should aim to court this generational talent. Instead, these teams appear most likely to compete for Soto based on their financial capabilities, roster configurations, and competitive aspirations.
New York Yankees
The Yankees would make a significant error by allowing Soto to slip away after his impressive debut season. Having adjusted to the intense atmosphere of New York seamlessly, Soto quickly became a vital player for the Yankees. After acquiring him last winter, the team has a prime opportunity to secure his long-term services. However, any hesitation regarding financial commitments could push Soto toward teams willing to meet his demands. Team owner Hal Steinbrenner must avoid the misconception that Soto would accept a hometown discount, as he is unlikely to do so. Soto was the missing piece that helped propel the Yankees back to the World Series after numerous postseason appearances during the Aaron Judge era.
Just six months ago, Steinbrenner noted at the MLB owners’ meetings that current payroll levels are unsustainable for the franchise. This statement raises concerns about the Yankees’ commitment to winning, especially given their financial resources. While the Yankees can afford Soto, agreeing to a contract that approaches $50 million annually, alongside Judge’s $40 million and Gerrit Cole’s $36 million, would complicate their competitive-balance tax situation.
Steinbrenner’s recent comments and his role in the league’s labor policy committee suggest he may prioritize fiscal responsibility over aggressive spending. The question remains whether he will reconcile this approach with the need to secure Soto while also advocating for owner interests in maintaining a controlled payroll.
Los Angeles Dodgers
While the Dodgers recently celebrated Shohei Ohtani’s MVP season and championship victory, his deferred contract allows them to remain competitive in the free-agent market. However, the Dodgers might not need another powerful bat, given their already stacked lineup. With Ohtani as their designated hitter and Mookie Betts in right field, Soto’s addition would necessitate a move to left field, where defensive concerns could arise as his contract progresses. Alternatively, he might have to transition to first base, a position he has not played professionally.
New York Mets
The Mets, led by billionaire owner Steve Cohen and president David Stearns, present a formidable challenge to the Yankees in the Soto sweepstakes. With their financial clout and a recent history of success, they could offer Soto a lucrative deal that would be hard to refuse. He could fit into their lineup as either a right fielder or designated hitter, enhancing their chances in the competitive NL East. The Mets’ recent playoff success, including a deep run against the Dodgers, may also appeal to Soto.
San Francisco Giants, Toronto Blue Jays
The Giants and Blue Jays share a common goal: both teams are eager to return to postseason play and are willing to invest in top-tier talent. After missing out on Ohtani last year, the Blue Jays are poised to make a significant move this offseason. The Giants, under new leadership from Buster Posey, may also pursue Soto aggressively, seeking a marquee player to revitalize their franchise. However, Soto’s desire to play for a contender may complicate matters for both teams, especially given their current standings in their respective divisions.
The Giants have previously failed to attract elite talent, making this offseason critical for their future. They have attempted to sign high-profile players in past free agency periods, indicating their commitment to building a competitive roster. The Blue Jays, on the other hand, have the financial flexibility to secure Soto, but their history with Boras could pose a challenge in negotiations.
Boston Red Sox, Philadelphia Phillies, Chicago Cubs
The Red Sox, Phillies, and Cubs can all theoretically afford Soto, but their chances of landing him are slim. For the Red Sox and Phillies, Soto may not address the core issues plaguing their rosters. The Cubs, while a storied franchise, have recently shown reluctance to commit to large contracts, with their most significant deal dating back to 2015. Even though Soto would bring star power to Wrigley Field, the Cubs may be hesitant to offer a contract that matches his worth.
As for the Cubs, their chances of acquiring Soto may have diminished after Cody Bellinger opted into his existing contract. While Soto would undoubtedly become a franchise cornerstone, the Cubs face financial constraints and a history of conservative spending. Nevertheless, they remain a marquee destination, and the possibility of flipping current outfielders could keep them in the conversation.
Washington Nationals
The Nationals stand apart in this discussion, not just for nostalgia but for their willingness to invest in talent. Rumors suggest a potential reunion with Soto, who previously received a $440 million offer before being traded to the Padres. While Soto would certainly enhance their young roster, the Nationals must demonstrate they can be competitive. His desire to play for a winning franchise may ultimately limit their chances, as they still have hurdles to overcome before becoming serious contenders.
Ultimately, the Soto sweepstakes will be one of the most captivating storylines of the offseason, with multiple teams vying for the chance to secure a generational talent. The Yankees may have the edge, but the competition is fierce, and the outcome remains uncertain.
