How to pitch to Shohei Ohtani, Aaron Judge, and MLB’s best hitters? John Smoltz offers insights on navigating the complexities of facing these elite players, especially with the pressure of the postseason looming.
In a recent discussion with MLB on FOX analyst John Smoltz, the Hall of Fame pitcher shared his strategies for confronting 11 of the most formidable hitters in this year’s playoff lineup.
1. Shohei Ohtani, Los Angeles Dodgers
Smoltz: Pitching to Ohtani requires a dual approach. He suggests having two distinct lanes: one that fades away and another that challenges him inside. Without this strategy, Ohtani’s remarkable ability to hit powerfully to all fields can be devastating. While he can swing at high fastballs, Smoltz warns that a lack of separation in pitch types will likely lead to trouble for any pitcher. He emphasizes the importance of mixing pitches, using splitters and sliders effectively, while also elevating fastballs to keep Ohtani off balance.
2. Aaron Judge, New York Yankees
Smoltz: Judge poses unique challenges as he narrows the opportunities to get him out. Smoltz recommends focusing on the lower strike zone while also mixing in off-speed pitches like sliders and curveballs once fastballs are established. The key is fastball location; if a pitcher fails to locate, Judge will capitalize. He advises that pitchers should not treat Judge the same way in the postseason as they did in the regular season, suggesting an approach that prioritizes avoiding giving him any chances to impact the game.
3. Juan Soto, New York Yankees
Smoltz: Soto’s command of the strike zone makes him a formidable opponent. He rarely swings at pitches outside the zone, which is why mixing up pitch types is crucial. Soto’s comfort level with two strikes makes him particularly dangerous, so pitchers must be cautious. Smoltz notes that Soto can be vulnerable to pitches above the strike zone but is disciplined enough to avoid chasing low pitches. The back foot breaking ball is a potential weapon against him, but his impact on Judge’s RBI count highlights his importance in the Yankees’ lineup.
4. Bryce Harper, Philadelphia Phillies
Smoltz: Harper’s aggressive approach at the plate opens opportunities for pitchers who can exploit his eagerness. Early engagement with quality pitches can yield results, but once Harper finds his timing, he becomes a difficult out. Smoltz suggests targeting the upper part of the strike zone while occasionally surprising him with breaking balls. The key takeaway is that every hitter has weaknesses; the challenge lies in minimizing the risk of leaving a pitch in a hittable zone.
5. Yordan Álvarez, Houston Astros
Smoltz: Álvarez, reminiscent of David Ortiz, displays a calm demeanor at the plate. His ability to handle various pitch types makes him a key player to avoid in crucial situations. Smoltz emphasizes the need for diverse pitching strategies, as Álvarez adapts well to different pitches. He advises that consistency is vital when facing such a skilled hitter.
6. Fernando Tatís Jr., San Diego Padres
Smoltz: Tatís Jr.’s strong frame and long levers allow him to generate significant power. He must be challenged with inside pitches and elevated offerings to keep him honest. Smoltz notes that pitchers must pay attention to Tatís Jr.’s swing patterns and adjust their secondary pitches accordingly to avoid leaving pitches in his power zone.
7, 8. Mookie Betts and Freddie Freeman, Los Angeles Dodgers
Smoltz describes Freeman as a unique hitter due to his ability to reach pitches that others cannot. His unconventional hitting style makes him challenging to pitch to, as he can effectively hit to all fields. He advises pitchers to change speeds and approach Freeman with a strategic mindset, as relying solely on fastballs can lead to trouble. Mookie Betts, also a key player, adds to the challenge of facing the Dodgers’ lineup, making it essential for pitchers to be on their game.
9. Bobby Witt Jr., Kansas City Royals
Smoltz: Witt Jr. remains an enigma for pitchers. His speed and ability to make contact complicate strategies, as he can reach base even on less-than-ideal pitches. Smoltz emphasizes the need for pitchers to study their approach and consider how to exploit any potential weaknesses while remaining wary of Witt Jr.’s talent.
10. José Ramírez, Cleveland Guardians
Smoltz: Ramírez’s shorter stature belies his power. Establishing fastball dominance is critical in keeping him off balance. Smoltz recommends challenging him with inside pitches to exploit any weaknesses while remaining cautious of his ability to drive the ball if left in the middle of the zone.
11. Luis Arráez, San Diego Padres
Smoltz: Arráez exemplifies a hitter who rarely swings and misses. His compact swing allows him to handle various pitches effectively. Smoltz advises that a slower approach may be necessary to disrupt his timing, as he thrives on velocity. He compares Arráez’s hitting style to legends like Tony Gwynn and Rod Carew, highlighting his exceptional ability to make contact.
