In a massive short-term commitment to Alex Bregman, the Red Sox show they’re serious again. This pivotal moment could signal a shift for a franchise that has struggled to find its footing in recent years.
After missing the playoffs for three consecutive seasons and five out of the last six, Boston has secured a player who embodies success. Alex Bregman, a key figure in Houston’s recent dominance, will don a different big-league uniform for the first time in 2025.
Bregman and the Red Sox have reportedly finalized a three-year, $120 million deal, which includes deferrals. This financial strategy reflects the franchise’s commitment to regaining its status as a competitive force in a challenging division, especially after finishing last in the AL East three times in five years.
Beyond his offensive prowess, Bregman brings invaluable leadership to a young roster. The Red Sox have a wealth of top prospects eager to make their mark in Major League Baseball, and Bregman’s experience could guide them as they transition into the big leagues.
In the past seven seasons, Bregman has amassed the second-most wins above replacement among all MLB third basemen, trailing only José Ramírez. While he may not be producing the All-Star caliber numbers of his earlier years, he remains a formidable player. His plate discipline and strong defense have kept him a step above the competition, maintaining a solid offensive output even as he faced challenges last season.
Bregman sought a contract exceeding $200 million this offseason. When that didn’t materialize, he considered various options, including a return to Houston for six years at $156 million or a deal with Detroit for $171 million over the same duration.
Related: MLB’s 6 riskiest contracts of the 2025 offseason
Had the deal not included deferrals, the average annual value would have placed Bregman among the highest-paid players in baseball. Even with the adjustments, the investment in a 31-year-old infielder raises questions about his recent performance trends, including a dip in his on-base percentage.
The Red Sox’s commitment to Bregman represents a significant step toward revitalizing the franchise. For the first time in years, they have made an enticing offer to attract top talent. Bregman’s power and hitting ability should thrive at Fenway Park, much like it did in Houston.
Importantly, Bregman has proven his capabilities away from home, posting impressive numbers at Fenway Park. In 21 games at the iconic stadium, he has recorded a 1.240 OPS and hit seven home runs.
What it means for the Red Sox
The Red Sox are attempting to reclaim their former glory.
Once a powerhouse with four World Series titles in 15 years, the team has faced challenges in recent seasons. While they are not back to their peak, this new direction is a step toward fulfilling the promise made by Red Sox chairman Tom Werner last year, when their biggest free-agent signing was a modest two-year deal with Lucas Giolito.
Since their last championship in 2018, the Red Sox have struggled to make a significant impact. In contrast, Bregman has been a cornerstone for the Astros, who have reached the World Series three times in six years.
Bregman’s stay in Boston may be short-lived. If he excels, he could opt out and explore free agency again. However, the substantial salary could also lead him to stay, especially if the Red Sox’s resurgence leads to a longer-term offer. The team has already made strategic additions to its pitching roster, including Garrett Crochet and Walker Buehler. Yet, these moves alone may not be enough to compete with teams like the Yankees and Orioles.
The Red Sox have needed a right-handed bat to complement their left-handed hitters. With prospects like Kristian Campbell and Marcelo Mayer on the horizon, the team ranked low in offensive production at shortstop and second base last season, highlighting the need for consistency in their lineup.
What it means for the Astros
The Astros face a challenging future.
Red Sox manager Alex Cora, among many others, has praised Bregman’s multifaceted impact on a team. His leadership was instrumental during Houston’s championship runs, and even José Altuve advocated for Bregman’s retention.
However, the Astros made a significant trade in December, moving three-time All-Star Kyle Tucker, which indicated their reluctance to invest in their championship core. This shift raises questions about the team’s direction.
With Bregman’s departure, Houston is transitioning to a new phase, with Isaac Paredes and top prospect Cam Smith stepping into key roles. The team still has star players like Altuve and Yordan Álvarez, but the loss of Bregman and Tucker marks a significant change in their roster dynamic.
The Astros have managed to adapt in the past, overcoming the exits of George Springer and Carlos Correa. However, with limited prospects on the way up, the durability of their recent success hangs in the balance.
