Cody Bellinger to the Yankees stands out as the better trade compared to Kyle Tucker to the Cubs. The Yankees’ decision to acquire Bellinger came at a much lower cost, allowing them to strengthen their roster without sacrificing top prospects. Meanwhile, the Cubs had to part with significant assets, including promising third base prospect Cam Smith, to secure Tucker, who is a one-year rental.
Which trade do you like better: The Yankees‘ deal for Cody Bellinger or the Cubs‘ swap for Kyle Tucker?
Deesha Thosar: Analyzing both trades reveals that Bellinger’s move to the Yankees is particularly advantageous, especially since they acquired him for a minimal price. Yankees general manager Brian Cashman traded only 30-year-old right-hander Cody Poteet to the Cubs. Poteet, with a career 3.80 ERA over 24 games, will primarily add depth to Chicago’s pitching staff. His previous season’s performance, highlighted by a 2.22 ERA in 24.1 innings, was beneficial for the Yankees but not enough to warrant a significant loss.
The decision to trade Poteet instead of a top prospect was straightforward for Cashman, akin to a simple winter coat choice in New York. The Yankees now have Bellinger, whose adaptability on the field enhances their lineup. Last season, Bellinger played all three outfield positions and first base, showcasing his versatility. This flexibility allows manager Aaron Boone to strategically position him wherever needed, depending on future roster moves.
Financially, the trade is equally sound for the Yankees. They are set to pay Bellinger $25 million in 2025, with the Cubs covering the remaining $5 million of his contract. If Bellinger opts out in 2026, the teams will split his $5 million buyout. The primary risk lies in Bellinger’s performance, especially after a dip in offensive numbers in 2024. However, given his previous success in 2023, the Yankees remain hopeful that they can help him regain his All-Star form.
On the other hand, Tucker’s acquisition by the Cubs is significant, but it came at a steep price. The Cubs traded three players, including top prospect Cam Smith, to the Astros for Tucker, who will only be with the team for one season. This trade was a strategic move for the Cubs, allowing them to enhance their roster while also shedding payroll, which could help them address other needs moving forward.
Rowan Kavner: While both trades have merit, the Cubs’ acquisition of Tucker could prove to be more impactful in the long run. Tucker is a standout player, likely to be one of the best in the league not named Juan Soto in 2025. His impressive performance in Houston places him among the top outfielders in terms of wins above replacement over the past five years.
The Yankees needed to bolster their outfield and first base positions, and Bellinger meets those requirements, despite not living up to his hefty $27.5 million salary last season. Ultimately, while both trades have their advantages, Bellinger’s move to the Yankees appears to be the more favorable deal, considering cost, roster fit, and potential future performance.
